The family tragedy Abagge
Isabel Kugler Mendes: no doubt about the innocence of the accused.
"I had the opportunity to go down Guaratuba and know the location of the" alleged satanic ritual. " Then if any doubt existed as to the innocence of all this is gone. "
Isabel Kugler Mendes, current Secretary of the Commission on Human Rights and Citizenship of the Bar of Paraná
Interview with Dr. . Kugler Isabel Mendes, current Secretary of the Commission on Human Rights and Citizenship of the Bar of Parana.
"I had the opportunity to go down Guaratuba and know the location of the" alleged satanic ritual. " Then if any doubt existed as to the innocence of all this is gone. "
Isabel Kugler Mendes, current Secretary of the Commission on Human Rights and Citizenship of the Bar of Paraná
Interview with Dr. . Kugler Isabel Mendes, current Secretary of the Commission on Human Rights and Citizenship of the Bar of Parana.
What is your opinion on the case of Guaratuba?
Isabel Kugler Mendes - The case of Guaratuba undoubtedly, was one of the most influential cases in the Brazilian judiciary, and why not tell the press. He crossed our borders and was released internationally, it is said that the news spread in over 50 countries, and was monitoring the national media until the end. I am aware of the facts through the press and in the past two months and while I was approached by family members Abbage as chairman of a watchdog on the Rights of Women, the City Council of Women of Curitiba. We received a complaint that Celina and Beatriz Abagge had been tortured. And then, whether guilty or innocent, he decided to seek the truth about the torture. Why torture is a heinous crime in any way, can any person be subjected to it. It is a constitutional precept that we must be respected. Initially we learn about the process and was surprised to find that from the beginning it was flawed. In the police report errors visible and primary. Examining the process - at the time was 5 volumes and I believe that today are almost 80, we raised the illegality, failures, errors and omission of the authorities and prepared a dossier showing the first and we send all this to the authorities and press. Work that had the support of lawyers and psychologists who then in service to the Council.
a second step, a separate work, I know the people involved, initially women. And what was my surprise when, six months passed since the arrest of them, I found that many still showed signs of violence, torture they were subjected. Beatriz Abbage had, in the fingers, numerous signs of burns, in fact, even today it still carries many of these signals. Also had cuts on his forehead scar on the forehead. These signs, she said, strapping buckles produced by the police torturers. And yet, biggest surprise was when she told in detail what had been raped at least two policemen. How had fainted not know if others also raped. D. Celina also reported the suffered tortures, which were many and cruel.
Whereas, as stated in the process, from the first time these two women found themselves facing the judicial authorities - judge and prosecutor - they reported that they had suffered torture and rape, whereas the signs of violence were visible, I was amazed to see that at no time was any action taken. Even that failed justice Beatriz Abbage denounced the rape, simply by registering, "she says she suffered sexual acts." Why? They do not need to open an inquiry, as the law requires and why the direction of research would be another confession by torture.
To interview the men was a huge difficulty. Only when I got laid for a short period as assistant defense - was an advocate dative, Dr. Stela. With men, there was less surprise because, although after ten months of imprisonment, all had visible signs of torture suffered for confessing. And still being tortured because the sacred right to private personal hygiene, by order of Judge Guaratuba. They really had a look wizards: huge nails, hair and long beards, and the lack of sun, skin a greenish white. There are pictures of that time showing that there is exaggeration in this account. Among the signs of torture suffered found: broken ribs, burn marks on the body, swelling, etc.. With the report of all seven witnesses involved and the various acts of violence committed against them by military police with copies of documents in the file, a second dossier was drafted and sent to the press and the authorities - the three powers - but as with the first file, no action was taken. The authorities have opted for the omission. Torture and truth are all issues that bother everyone.
Over the years - I think the women were arrested eight years - continued monitoring, browsing, monitoring, viewing conditions and fighting for human rights those people. Let me be clear that I or the Council for Women, never defend these people for the crime they were being accused. Other lawyers have made this defense. Yes we advocate, human rights, to which we all Brazilian citizens are entitled. These people could not have been tortured into confessing a crime he did not cometeram.Um crime which remains hidden in the shadows of fear, cowardice, the indifference of many. Our Constitution is clear in providing that no one shall be subjected to torture, degrading treatment, cruel and inhumane, and these people were. But is the rule, the innocent "confess" under torture, support the guilty because they know they will be freed.
Subsequently, I had the opportunity to go down Guaratuba and know the location of the "alleged satanic ritual." Then if any doubt existed as to the innocence of all this has disappeared. When I was there the plant was still operating with 25 employees, in fact it happened the épo0ca were 54 employees. Seeing the place - a room of about six square meters full of furniture - anyone recognize there is altogether impossible to place something like a ritual, or even a meeting with more than 3 or 4 people. A child could ever have been trapped there, confined for more than 30 hours as reported. A room totally open, with employees coming and going all the time, picking up tools to regulate the machines to beat point. Furthermore, the terrain - huge - is surrounded by homes and ends at bay, for they entered the boats that transported wood to the mill caxetais. There I saw a variety of boats. If someone makes a ritual and seek to hide a body, was just having got there! The bay with one of the ships and dumped the body in the sea, the mangrove (which would be eaten by crabs) and this would never be found. Now, think about it: take one body at a distance of more than 5 miles from the scene of the alleged ritual, putting the key to the boy's home disappeared, slippers and personal belongings found beside the body, is a blatant act of making known what is not! Clearly the intent to manufacture evidence to a desired end: to incriminate the innocent.
Finally I would say - was always my opinion, have to explain who is the accuser, Mr. Diogenes Caetano, uncle of the boy .. Evandro political enemy of Mayor Aldo Abagge, jettisoned traditional society Guaratuba, attended by family Abagge and not by remembering that sua.Vale Guaratuba, off-season, is a small town. Throughout the proceedings the accuser, Diogenes Caetano, manipulated the simple folk the county for public demonstrations. I understand he was never investigated other factors contributed to this tragedy that has befallen the family Abagge and so many others. Because the family of little Evan is also the victim. Another: the political order of the moment. Mayor Aldo Abagge within the Association of Mayors of the Coast, not too shared the thinking of the then governor. Which may explain why there was no willingness by the government to investigate and clarify the facts. Other important factors: the Police Department - Eagle Group - has conducted abundant research has examined the allegations of Mr. Diogenes Caetano about the ritual and nothing has been proven. But he managed to reach the then Secretary Favette, which, they said, was to be deposed before the public outcry over the disappearance of 14 children. Possibly he saw the Secretary Favette in denouncing anything that could have repercussions and prevent their exit. Avoided, and the repercussions went beyond anything that the authorities imagine. The ingredients strong enough to ignite anything: CHILD. RELIGION, FAMILY (traditional) and POLICY (mayor). Rapid fire spread to and did not give more to insure: the lie prevailed.
There was no further possibility of return, and went so far as it arrived. The confessions obtained by the PM had to be kept standing. And, thank God, some of these unfortunate people, were acquitted. As Ms. Celina and Beatrice, the jurors acquitted by 6 votes to 1 by proving that the body found was not a child of seven years, but a child of 10 to 11 years. After two other defendants were acquitted, but three of the boys, who had not afford to hire lawyers, were eventually convicted. No one knows why, but one still has arrested: Vincent de Paul.
What can be said that there is justice in future cases like this from recurring?
Isabel Kugler Mendes - I understand that the responsibility of civilian police is very large in research and development of an investigation. She is the judicial police and not the PM, who is responsible, in this case, the responsibility of torture to obtain confessions. We are in a case - coincidence occurred on the coast - that is the case of the Morro do Boi. . Two accused: who is really to blame? The evidence will tell, I believe. Hence the police investigation to be essential for elucidation of the crime. If the investigation is poorly made it is difficult for the judiciary and the accumulation process, often, keep him from going to bottom to prevent injustice, as the case Guaratuba.
And still, the whining, hatred, anger, recklessness of the people - in the case of Diogenes Caetano - cause family tragedies like this. Destroy reputations. Undermine and weaken the society and the law. Acts like this case, destroy and undermine family structures: the family Abagge as a whole - a respected family of solid tradition - was deeply shaken and is still today suffer the effects of this tragedy. Many lives were lost: Dr Aldo Abagge died of cancer in the stomach of so much suffering. The father of D. Celina, wept until he died eleven months, the point of tears covering his face wound. Oswaldo's father died Joiner and so many others, also suffering and pain. Many people suffered and still suffer, as the family of the martyr Evandro Caetano, the consequences of this sad and tragic case.
mean anything else to quit? Isabel Kugler
Mendes - I ask God that the whole truth, in this case, to appear - clean and transparent - that can be done justice for all, that truth is always ahead that falsehood and evil are defeated. That those responsible for justice to be aware of the importance of their decisions for a just and humane society. And as the poet said:
"What forgiveness is sacred
That faith is infinite
That man is free
That justice will survive."
From Blog If Guaratuba
In the photos, Celina and Beatriz Abagge - Dr. Elizabeth Kugler Mendes
;
Office of Senator Alvaro Dias of 11/2009
Read more
...
"Nobody can hurt me without my consent."
Beatriz Abagge
I'm not nightmares, they never abandoned the peace of mind and in my heart, I learned this while I was unjustly imprisoned the agents and those who condemned me could completely control the situation environment where I was and could do whatever they want with my body that I acted as an observer of my destiny.
You know why? BECAUSE I COULD DECIDE WITHIN ME THAT AFFECT ME MI because I chose what my reaction I exercised my opção.Isso to me is dignity.
Many have no dignity, and that's exactly how I see people trying to scold me, offend me, insult me, I'm not destruir.Eu controlled by the treatment I receive from others .
In Orkut
http://www.orkut.com.br/Main # CommMsgs? cmm = 16875593 & tid = 2506999569933303405 & na = 1 & nst = 1
I believe in Abagge
http://www.orkut.com/Community.aspx?cmm=14504136
Blog The Tragedy of Abagge
http:/ / atragediadasabagges.blogspot.com /
0 comments:
Post a Comment